Monday, March 12, 2012

Oh, Shit. This IS What Democracy Looks Like.

A part of Glenn's point is well-taken; it is crazier, in a philosophical, categorical sense, to believe that the President is some kind of absolute monarch with the power to launch wars of conquest and assassinate his own citizens and so on, but down here in the phenomenal world in which objects and actions must be judged, alas, by their actual attributes alone, the Gulfstream Media is factually and, uh, actually correct: wherefore there ain't never gonna be a motherfucking Department of Peace, therefore Dennis Kucinich wuz nuts.  Sanity and insanity aren't really absolute values, are they?  I mean, they're positional; they stand relative to the times in which they are uttered in judgment.  Or, like, dude: the human condition is insanity, and sanity consists simply of those insane sentiments which, because they are sufficiently widely shared, appear normal.  I don't know; point is: all the things that Glenn says are crazy, the wars and killings and endless so-called failed policies, are not crazy because they are so goddamned real; they have all been prestodigitated by thousands of years of state-backed, taxpayer-funded avarice from sick delusion into total normalcy.  What's crazy is thinking you can unscramble those eggs and put that BOOM back into the stick of dynamite.


On the question of Grand-Slam's larger impact, Glenn seems to be of the opinion that he is a molar, ingrown, subtly undermining the rest of those mean chompers:
For one, enacting legislation is not the only way to have an important impact on our political culture. Shining light on otherwise-ignored issues, advocating rarely-heard political positions, using one’s platform to highlight the corruption of those in power and to challenge their warped belief systems are all vitally important functions. Advocacy of that sort may not produce immediate, tangible successes, but it is a prerequisite for changing prevailing political mores and persuading citizens to think differently.
I have a hypothesis that the word citizen is, for many minds, a safety word; what was whipping along at a fine pace comes to a swift and sudden halt, lest it do any actual damage.  Is this what Dennis Kucinich was doing?  See, here, well, um, I have long been under the impression that what Dennis Kucinich was doing was providing a reliably quote-unquote liberal outlier, a lonely tentpole on the far, far side of the bombing range where the Democratic party pitches its big tent, around which the sort of folks who overpay for yoga instruction and carry their own bags to the grocery store could crowd, having convinced themselves that its slender shadow is the shade.  A few paces to its left is a single, well-occupied dining room chair, upon which rest all of Ron Paul's supporters; it's their seat at the table, get it?  Look, people within institutions serve institutional functions, whether the like it or not, whether they know it or not.  Does Dennis Kucinich help you to continue to believe that you are an, oh, god, citizen?  That by speaking out you are "changing prevailing political mores"?  Maybe all isn't lost . . . maybe . . . maybe I ought to continue to participate . . . it may not produce any immediate, tangible successes, but, given time . . . attitudes change . . . people change . . .

And this is how you end up reliably offering your consent to one or other gang of murdering psychopaths.  So who's crazy, here, the murdering psychopaths, or the fella who keeps handing them the keys to the gun cabinet?  The old saw about the real definition of insanity is the truth: it consists of the endless repetition of the same action with the expectation of a different result.  If the Democratic party can contain a Kucinich, it must be less evil than the evil rethuglican menace, right?  If the Republicans have a Ron Paul, they must be at least somewhat, marginally more committed to some kind of reasonable limits on the reach and scope of the federal government, right?  No, wrong, wrong!  If a fucking candy bar contains real coconut, that does not make it a fruit; if you fruits drink enough Miller Ultra Lite, you will still get fat.

34 comments:

Anonymous said...

Meh.

mistah charley, ph.d. said...

the sort of folks who overpay for yoga instruction and carry their own bags to the grocery store

around here the political jurisdictions have slapped a bag tax on and so "carrying your own bags" has spread from the upscale organic food "whole paycheck" market to the middle class supermarkets

Professor Coldheart said...

The old saw about the real definition of insanity is the truth: it consists of the endless repetition of the same action with the expectation of a different result.

See, this turn of phrase always bugged me, because it's not how "real" "insane" people operate. Genuinely insane people don't expect different results when they yell at the bus stop posters or organize their drinking glasses by age or vote for the Ruling Party. Expectation doesn't enter into it; for them, the act is enough. They're deontological.

If the subway driver ground the train to a halt and said, "You're right; the Jews are using lizards to police us; what should we do about it?", the schizophrenic wouldn't have an answer. He hasn't visualized that day. He's yelling because, fuck it, sometimes you just got shit you got to yell about.

Insanity is the endless repetition of the same action oblivious to the result.

Minor nitpick, but that's what the Internet is for. Welcome back.

Leonard said...

Greenwald sure does write a lot of words to say something rather banal.

Leonard said...

IOZ is right: "citizen" is a safety word, by which I think he means it is both duckspeak and crimestop.

A better word for our status within the progressive technocratic regime is "subject". Ponder your helplessness, and the proper response to it.

Montag said...

i forget to take those damn grocery bags all the time.

hey, Reagan made French fries a vegetable and Bush did the same for ketchup. putting the two together is still a legitimate salad, right? (i'm trying to eat better.)

Sorry said...

But he kept us out of HAARP!

http://thomas.loc.gov/cgi-bin/query/z?c107:H.R.2977.IH:

Welcome back, sir.

TedTheJackal said...

"having convinced themselves that its slender shadow is the shade" ... may have to appropriate that.

I've never confused Kucinich with the Democratic party or Ron Paul with the Republicans, but then I'm in the rational fringe.

And I like Einstein's approach to defining a thing- come up with a testable definition and apply it. Everything else is substantially pointless semantics.

Anonymous said...

IOZ is best understood as a Christian anarchist.

puppylander said...

advocacy and awareness, eh?

i wonder if glenn has bought his "action kit" yet from those aryan brownshirts at "invisible children"?

davidly said...

...but down here in the phenomenal world in which objects and actions must be judged, alas, by their actual attributes alone, the Gulfstream Media is factually and, uh, actually correct: wherefore there ain't never gonna be a motherfucking Department of Peace...
I'm pretty sure you just plagiarized the prez's Nobel acceptance thingy.

Fannie Farmer (Mrs.) said...

Montag asserts i'm trying to eat better

Our friends at the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine say:


What type of diet is best for disease prevention and to maintain a healthy weight? The best diet is one that you can stick with for life. A healthy diet is a lifestyle, not a fad that is dangerous or difficult to maintain.

Abundant evidence suggests that the most healthful diets set aside animal products and also reduce fats in general, while including large amounts of vegetables and fruits. Eliminating meat and dairy products from your diet is a powerful step in disease prevention.

http://pcrm.org/health/diets/vsk/vegetarian-starter-kit

LA Confidential Pantload said...

Well, I'm trying to eat bitter, so fuck y'all.

rob payne said...

Yeah, Greenwald is changing the world just like Digby did. I think he is talking more about himself than Kucinich. A great post, glad you are back.

Joe said...

I have to agree with Prof Coldheart's nitpick. Doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result sounds more like the definition of stubbornness.

lucid said...


Abundant evidence suggests that the most healthful diets set aside animal products and also reduce fats in general


Yeah, if you want to develop any number of chronic inflammation diseases that plague all those US consumers of non and low fat products...

Anonymous said...

"The old saw about the real definition of insanity is the truth: it consists of the endless repetition of the same action with the expectation of a different result."

been roundly beaten to this punch, but seriously, that isn't a functioning definition of insanity.

it posits the belief in an unbreakable causal nexus. now THAT'S fucking insane.

Eerily Lackadaisical said...

It strikes me that you're implicitly calling Kucinich a "gate-keeper", in precisely the same way that your old SlateMate Appolonius used to call Chomsky a "gate-keeper" re the 9/11 Inside Job conspiracy ...

Happy Jack said...

I'd say a border collie instead of a gatekeeper.

High Arka said...

(/sarcasm Mrs. Fannie, if only we mammals can eliminate dairy products, we will return to our roots as decomposing organic compounds.

/end sarcasm
Also, it's the AMA, big pharm. and long-term land-use corps. pushing studies that encourage vegetable-only. Rather like the NYT pushing bomb-Iran.)

Anonymous said...

Arka, you fucking retard...

Anonymous said...

Since Arka is completely correct on the veggie diet agenda, I am forced to re-evaluate my opinion of him.

If you want to be healthy and fit, and not just skinny, eat meat, eat fat, reduce carbs. But because of supply and demand, I'm ok with progressives sticking to their wheatgrass and okra.

Anonymous said...

Not enough Proggs THAT committed to the cause, I'm afraid.

The Dull Sycophant

michael simpkins said...

I can't quite understand the citizen safety word hypothesis. Could someone walk this dullard through it?

Christopher said...

...carry their own bags to the grocery store...

Where I live plastic bags are illegal and the grocery stores charge ten cents per paper bag. I reckon the cost of paper bags has always been factored into the cost of groceries, but now that I have a choice, I'm cheaping it out.

Anonymous said...

It is truly surreal to witness Arka being a smug prig in one comment to a peace lovin hippie in another (complete with her odd obsession with "antilife" and what me? attitude), and then back to being a creepy, violent fascist.

All that said, Arka identifies as a woman. Please stop calling her "him."

High Arka said...

Oh, cools, where does the fascism come in?

Or the peace-loving? The dichotomy between pacifism and drone strikes is as silly as the one between the American right and the American left. The chaos of the guillotine really is all that will save some situations--as long as it's not a fronting "defector" lord running the circus. As they say, life is short--play hard.

IOZ is, far and away, one of the more amusing calmatives out there, and his critiques of the others are generally more accurate than they would be about him (if they deigned to notice him formally), but he's still a calmative.

And why not? Gotta feed the monster, or the monster gonna come after you. Pass the fucking brie, and didja hear what stupo-crazy thing [rethug] said last week? Hahaha munch munch slurp!

Gabe Ruth said...

Yo Arks, would the current situation qualify as being fit for the chaos of the guillotine? That seems to be the assertion when you call the Monsieur a calmative, whatever that means (but I assume it was meant derisively), yet I have trouble rectifying such a belief with your previous calls for teaching the next generation to live in peace and harmony. Or did your persecution here convince you that all was lost, so liberty, equality, fraternity, or death?

Kucinich and probably Paul (though it pains me to say it) are calmatives (I think?) and IOZ sees this. Anyone pushing the guillotine, while certainly not a calmative, doesn't mean well. If chaos would be an improvement, better a universally armed society where life is cheap than the mob murdering the villain of the week. Not that either will prevail against the USG without peak oil or a pandemic.

Nony, I hear ya on the Christian anarchism. Been all down hill since the Edict of Milan.

Anonymous said...

Not that [Lebanon1980 or Persia1980] will prevail against the USG without peak oil or a pandemic.

To live through TWO system collapses in a lifetime would be a bit too "interesting". But 'Merkin exceptionalism my ass. USG will join the trash heap one way or another.


Nony, I hear ya on the Christian anarchism. Been all down hill since the Edict of Milan.

The monachization of the church hierarchy has been a pretty effective counter for a long while.

anne said...

she (s'e) comes in for a wee moment of reading on a bre ak from her ('er ) busy .., pleasure ,little laughter .. read ..i am amused .. by all .. . (even leonard.. here .. since first a snicker in looking over the fall before last .. . ( i wish that he could deal with my liking the flow of no caps ,and something of the sea ,ocean etc .. . ) .. ... / AhhhhGUILlotine.. , maybe i shouldn't have mentioned that i'm a little french .. (of setting , and pacing and huguenot.. .) . when the suggest was made a few posts back that arka (high ) come down (high )off of her cross ..they need the wood .. my thought was ..yes .. . for the anne stake ..she (s'e ) makes such a lovely center piece ..for all occasions .. ,a peace loving love in moment .. .

Anonymous said...

... and lest anyone gets their hopes too high, even when USG vanishes in a cloud'o'dust, we'll remain the same ignorant jerkoff douchebags.

The Dull Sycophant

High Arka said...

You're all wonderful, and also capable of so much more. If you don't like it, why are you playing this game, anyway?

Anonymous said...

There is but one truly serious philosophical problem and that is suicide. Judging whether life is or is not worth living amounts to answering the fundamental question of philosophy. All the rest - whether or not the world has three dimensions, whether the mind has nine or twelve categories - comes afterwards. These are games.

The Myth of Sisyphus

Eerily Lackadaisical said...

nonny@5:55

ou sont les mamans d'antan?

http://www.google.com/search?q=ma+mere+est+morte+l%27etranger&rls=com.microsoft:en-us:IE-SearchBox&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&sourceid=ie7&rlz=1I7WZPC_enUS418